My gf and I greeted the news that Mario Batali and partners would be opening a restaurant in Hong Kong with glee. Batali is a celebrity chef in the US and we’ve been watching him on TV for years. He’s got a bunch of restaurants, mostly in New York (he has two outposts in Singapore). We’re big fans of the Spain …. On the Road Again show that he did with Mark Bittman a few years ago. Batali’s as famous for his look – red hair and beard, plaid shorts, orange Crocs – as he is for his food, maybe even more so. I know the whole celebrity chef deal, we had no expectation of him being in the kitchen, standing at the pass, personally supervising our food. But we figured on an enjoyable evening and that’s very much what it was although the food itself was uneven.
I mentioned to a cousin of mine that we’d be going. This cousin used to work for Batali in New York and dismissed Lupa as “pasta and peasant food.” (One might accuse him of sour grapes but I’m proud to say that he won a James Beard award this year.) At any rate, I told him that he didn’t know the Hong Kong market, that Batali’s approach would be somewhat unique here and we were looking forward to trying it.
So I booked Lupa for my gf’s birthday dinner. I knew in advance that this was coming less than one week after their official opening and I’d heard there were some rough patches during their soft opening phase but it was her birthday so I crossed my fingers and hoped for the best.
If you look at Lupa’s menu, the first thing that will probably strike you is how reasonable their prices are, if you take into account celebrity chef, “fine dining,” Central location. Many of the main courses are in the HK$200 range, more or less. I spoke with one of the managers there, a local Hong Kong guy who has worked in many restaurants in town and he told me that when he first looked at the menu, he had to ask if there was some mistake, that the prices seemed too low.
(In case you’re wondering, there are no photos to accompany this review. I don’t believe that taking food photos in restaurants is appropriate at times and this was one of those times.)
So we arrived at the restaurant, which is on the 3rd floor of the new LHT Tower on Queens Road. You walk in and are greeted by this giant bronze statue of a wolf (“lupa”) suckling Romulus and Remus. It’s dramatic but a little odd. The room itself is nicely designed, not too formal, wood where it needs to be, kind of a classic but modern feel to it. Despite having booked 3 weeks in advance, we were given a small table near the bar. We asked if we could get switched to a larger table (the place was more than half empty at 7:30 but did fill up later) and were told we could be moved to a different location but same size table. We decided to stay put.
The sommelier helped us select a wine and came up with something we liked at HK$380 – wines start at HK$300 and ascend into the stratosphere, as you might expect. And then onto the food.
The bread basket came by and the guy put one slice of bread onto each of our plates. One small slice of bread. All by itself. We had to ask the waiter if there was any butter or vinegar and then he offered up a small bowl of olive oil and balsamic. Throughout the night we’d see waiters bringing these little white bowls to tables and had to wonder why it didn’t come at the same time as the bread – or at least get offered?
I ordered the “Selection of Carne Grande”, a selection of meats that included prosciutto, lingua, salame, coppa and testa for HK$188. I wanted to get this because Batali’s parents are famous for their artisan salumi – I doubted that this would be sourced from them but figured that some care and attention went into the selection. Served on a wooden carving block and drizzled with olive oil and that was all. The various meats were nice but … just some pieces of various cured pork sausages on a block of wood to be eaten by itself? It was a bit of a letdown. I felt, rightly or wrongly, that they should have gone further, perhaps paired this with different cheeses, put a pickle or some sort of garnish on there (there was a tiny bit of green with the lingua), maybe a biscuit or something?
We wanted to share a salad and went with grilled radicchio with scamorza (HK$98) – grilled lettuce dressed with balsamic vinaigrette and with a layer of smoked mozzarella cheese melted on top. I didn’t feel that the flavors were well balanced here and the cheese seemed lacking in taste.
On to the mains. I had been staring at the hanger steak for a long time but at the last moment switched and ordered the veal saltimbocca (HK$298) because I couldn’t remember the last time I had veal and the menu said it was Dutch veal, which many will tell you is the best. The menu said prosciutto, sage and spinach. Honestly, I got no prosciutto taste from this at all and while the veal was pounded thin I think it could have been a bit more tender.
On the other hand, my gf ordered the braised pork shoulder with averna and cucumber (HK$208 – glazed in apple and Sicilian bitter liquor) and this was a home run. We were told that it was braised for at least 4 hours. It was fall-apart tender and had a beautiful char on the outside, and all of the flavors really came together well on this one. My gf only allowed me to have one small bite and then she practically inhaled the rest.
We did have room for dessert and wanted to order the lupa tartufo but they told us they were out of it – and had been out of it for two days. So we went with the peanut chocolate bar (HK$108), drizzled with chocolate sauce and a small scoop of gelato on the side. My gf had previously told one of the managers that this was her birthday dinner and there was a candle on the plate and they’d written “happy birthday” in chocolate as well. This dessert was also a winner.
We followed that up with a latte for my gf and an espresso for me. The bill, including a bottle of wine and the 10% service charge, came in at around HK$1500.
So, what did we like? We liked the pork shoulder and the dessert and the wine. We liked the look and feel of the place and felt that the staff worked really hard to make us comfortable.
What didn’t we like? I wouldn’t rush to order the same starter or salad or main dish again. I might go for the hanger steak or one of the pastas next time.
Yes, there will be a next time, we think the place has promise. One of the managers there, someone who has worked for Batali for a long time, told me he thought that a restaurant can open as a good restaurant but needs 6 or 7 months to develop into a great one. It was the staff there more than anything else that won us over – friendly and helpful to the extreme.
By the way, Lupa also features a large outdoor terrace. There’s no view to speak of from this terrace but it’s well-designed and comfortable. The menu is slightly different – same starters and salads, no pasta or main courses, but adds 6 different types of pizza. It strikes me as an alternative spot to stop for a drink after work if I’m feeling so inclined. Next time we go together we’ll probably try the terrace and the pizza.