MacBook Air or Pro?
Posted by SpikeFeb 13
I’m in need of a new laptop. Maybe “want” more than “need” but even so ….
Despite my love for iOS devices, I remain something of a Windows person, even though I’m a bit reticent to admit that. The few times I’ve “switched” to Mac in the past were never quite comfortable experiences for me. But the times have changed – so much of what I do on a computer now is in a browser window that the OS starts to pale into insignificance. Except that Mac manages memory better than Windows. And I love the multi-touch gestures on the Mac trackpad. (No, I’m not interested in Linux.) I don’t see any serious hardware competition on the PC side for Macs at the moment. Samsung is about to come out with a light weight notebook that will be serious competition for the MacBook Air but the base price will be US$1,700.
I do have a 2 year old MacBook (not Pro). A year ago I gave it to my gf and I think if I tried to get it back I’d risk losing a hand (or worse).
So the question then becomes what to buy. MacBook Pro – heavier duty specs than the Air but how heavy duty do I need to get? I’m not a gamer, I’m not crunching huge spreadsheets, I’m not writing code. The Pro line is rumored to be receiving an update next month, to Intel’s new Sandy Bridge processor. Nice.
But weight is really important to me. As in LIGHT weight. That would seem to indicate the Air is a better choice for me than the Pro. But which Air? For size and weight, obviously the 11 inch model is the winner. But the 11 inch only comes with a 1.4 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo processor – this can be upgraded to a 1.6 GHz if one chooses the 11 inch model with the 256 gig solid state drive. The base on the 13 inch is a 1.86 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo, which seems like it ought to be noticeably better. (That in turn is upgradeable to a 2.13 GHz processor, again only if you get the 256 gig SSD.) Base memory is 2 gigs of RAM but you can get a unit with 4 gigs.
What am I going to run on it? A browser. iTunes. MS Office. Maybe Drupal. Adobe Lightroom – that’s the one that has me concerned. How does it perform on a 1.86 processor? Also planning to tether my DSLR to the laptop. Nikon makes great software for that and there’s even a third party app that allows you to connect via iPhone or iPad once you’re tethered to the laptop.
Yesterday I actually dropped into a couple of places in Wanchai. None of them had the Air in stock with 4 gigs of RAM; one shop told me there’s a two week waiting period at the moment. I did think about doing some shopping in Central or Causeway Bay or Mong Kok today but the weather’s just too crappy. Monday, Monday ….
Hmmm, just found this: ”Working with large RAW files on the ’Air is definitely not recommended.” Yikes.



5 comments
Comment by Fernando on February 13, 2011 at 6:34 pm
FWIW, I’m running last year’s MBP 13 inch, 2.4GHz Intel Core 2 Duo, with 6GB RAM and SSD. It runs Lightroom really well.
Comment by Phil on February 13, 2011 at 11:11 pm
If you are using it as your photographer’s laptop get the pro. It is really that simple. The air is okay if you are syncing jpegs but if you shoot RAW you need the appropriate tools for the job and the Air ain’t it.
Comment by Hong Kong Tech Phooey on February 13, 2011 at 11:40 pm
The newest MBA is nice really for those on the move MAC applications, that is if you have quite a bit of stuff to type up, be it with Pages or Numbers (don’t use Microsoft Office anymore, iWork is pure lovely just even to look at). Lightroom is ok for on the fly touch-up but definitely not for loading up tons of RAW files to work on at the end of the day (leave that to the desktop) plus given the limited storage on the SSD, you don’t want to do that, even if you store your pics over the cloud. Tried tethering with my Sony A900 together with Lightroom and it works fine with my MBA config.
Size wise, forget about the 11 inch MBA, tried it out at the store and the screen are WAY too small for US to look that though it’s really light and compact but what’s the use if you can’t read shit off it.
Speed wise, the MBA is fine even with the 1.86 GHz, guess I don’t have much stuff that need that much processing power. The applications I uses most daily on it now are:
Pages
Numbers
Postbox2 (excellent email client)
Busycal (substitute for MS Outlook)
NewsRack
Kindle (actually not bad at all on the Mac)
Numbers
APP STORE (LOL)
Another alternative is getting the refurbished MacBook Pro 2.53GHz, listed now for HK$8,688 for 4GB Ram and 250GB Hdd on the Hong Kong Apple Store. Not a bad deal at all.
My call….the basic config is good enough, HK$9,888 not a bad deal. If you want it fast, tried calling all the Broadway and Fortress stores and ask whether they have stock, some of the megastores do carry one or two pieces.
Good luck shopping.
Comment by woodenkimono on February 14, 2011 at 5:03 am
Also, you get Firewire 800 and an SD card reader on the Pro. I have a 2009 MBP Pro 13″ 2.26GHz, 4 GB RAM and I love it! I think that you find the Air to be a little lightweight for what you want to do.
Comment by Friend of Casey on February 14, 2011 at 5:53 pm
Wait until 11 March for the MacBook Pro refresh. Then get one. The Air is nice but underpowered.