Xmas Trees?
Posted by SpikeNov 30
I’m 55 years old and I’ve never had an Xmas tree. Not terribly surprising, I’m a Jewish atheist. And depending on my mood, symbols of Christianity, especially the Roman Catholic church, can serve as reminders of close to 2,000 years of Christians oppressing and murdering Jews. Okay, that’s a bit heavy-handed on my part. At any rate, while I no longer believe in the Jewish religion, Jewish culture is deeply ingrained within me.
Last year, my gf never mentioned putting up any Xmas decorations in the house. This year, far more secure in the relationship, she’s demanding a Christmas tree. And as much as I don’t care for the idea, if this is “our” house and not just mine, then I think I have to respect her wishes. And maybe I can sneak a few Jewish ornaments onto the tree – if such things exist in Hong Kong. (One year a relative actually installed one of these in her home and we decided we’d call it a Hanukkah Bush.)
She doesn’t want to wait until the week before Xmas to get the tree, she wants to get it ASAP – presumably so it can die long before the actual holiday. (Unless we go for a fake one?) But I have no idea where to get such a beast. Where does one buy Xmas trees in HK?
While I have no interest in the Christian religion, I do enjoy good historical documentaries and the BBC makes some of the best. So we’ve been watching A History of Christianity, presented by Oxford professor Diarmaid MacCulloch. The first episode of this six-part series traces the development of Eastern churches, which apparently reached all the way into central China by the 7th century (and then all but disappeared by the 9th). The second episode traces the rise of the Catholic church and how Rome, the center of the empire that killed the Christ and then proceeded to persecute and kill Christians for 300 years, ended up becoming the religious center of the world for more than a billion of them.
I like the facts and figures behind this, the demystification, the straight-forward presentation of historical events – actual events, not myths or fables. MacCulloch, who to my eyes looks more than a bit like Randy Newman, gets to wander all over the world and you get that great BBC documentary photography, itself worth the price of admission. But some of the info is quite dry and the editors attempt to jazz it up with all sorts of tricks – from MacCulloch sitting in a pub hoisting a pint while discussing a topic to quick cutting between lovely travelogue shots of people in markets or boats in harbors while he’s talking. As a matter of opinion, the material presented isn’t merely dry, it’s presented in a somewhat disorganized, scattershot fashion. I suspect it’s better presented in the accompanying book and I might be tempted to pick it up.
I don’t suppose the BBC would ever produce a “History of the Jews” series (or have they already done so?) but I think such a series would also make engrossing viewing – tracing the path of the Jewish people across Europe and Asia for almost 2,000 years, Israel, the Inquisition and so on. By the time I’ve finished watching MacCulloch’s series I’ll probably know more about Christianity than I know about Judaism.



9 comments
Comment by The KMB on November 30, 2009 at 3:13 pm
There was an offer from IKEA to get real scandinavian Xmas trees. There was a certain deadline to order them. Maybe you check – I think they buy some extra qty’s for last – minute buyers. As I remember they wiill arrive in HK around December 8 or something………….
Comment by Lanta on November 30, 2009 at 5:23 pm
Go for the tree and treat it as a festival. Thats supposidly how it all started back with the Pagans. Christmas never really ment religion with me, it was always turkey, presents and trying to avoid watching The Queen.
I think there might still be a bit of “bad feelings” between BBC and Israel over news coverage. Wishing for a balanced history of the Jews might not be on the cards soon. History and especially Religious history is always somebody particualr perception of the events.
http://www.b3ta.com/board/9710934
Comment by Don Quixote on November 30, 2009 at 7:29 pm
There’s a garden centre on the left just after you pass The Giverny (en route to Sai Kung).
IKEA deliver Noble Firs.
Wellcome do Noble Firs and Douglas Firs for about $600.
Comment by Benjamin on November 30, 2009 at 11:58 pm
Paul Johnson’s ‘A History of the Jews’ is a really, really good book, covering exactly the content to mentioned above.
http://www.amazon.com/History-Jews-Paul-M-Johnson/dp/0060915331
Of course, it’s Paul Johnson, but if you can get past any negative connotations the name conjures, he’s a fine writer and genuine historian.
Comment by Spike on December 1, 2009 at 12:00 am
Actually I just downloaded the first chapter of that (and one other book on the topic) to my Kindle, will check it out. Thanks!
Comment by Jim on December 1, 2009 at 10:12 am
My understanding was that Christmas trees are a relic of paganisim so just enjoy it without thinking about any of the religious crap. Painting yourself blue and human sacrifice are optional!
Comment by Paul on December 1, 2009 at 1:37 pm
Christmas is not a religious festival in many households.
My family has celebrated since I was a kid 50 years ago, and never had any Christian symbols involved.
It’s just another holiday.
How many people in Hong Kong know that Jesus celebrates his birthday on December 25th?
Now don’t get me started on people here and in the Philippines singing Jingle Bells, or White Christmas.
I get offended hearing such crap in ParkNShop and in shopping arcades.
It’s laughable, and falling into the American Christmas fantasy.
Does it snow in Bethlehem?
Thank God I’m an atheist.
Comment by Richard on December 1, 2009 at 5:08 pm
Paul – it may or may not snow in Bethlehem, but it definitely snows, sometimes quite heavily, in Jerusalem – which is just up the road. It snowed a little when I was living there in 1994, and there have been a couple of winters with significant snowfall since then. Using a snow motif in Hong Kong is more than faintly ridiculous though!
The History of Christianity series is very good, and I do like the way he mixes historical, political and philosophical issues without getting bogged down in actual religious stuff. Note that it’s co-produced by the Open University (the UK’s main part-time/distance-learning university) so it is probably at least partly meant as teaching material.
I’ve got a very large book on my shelf at home called “A History of the Jews in the Modern World”, which I have to admit I’ve never actually opened…
Fortunately, my gf has not asked to have Christmas decorations at home, and I’m not quite sure how I would deal with it – I suspect we’d end up with some strictly non-denominational lights and not much more. I prefer to go out and see public displays anyway
Comment by fumier on December 2, 2009 at 5:13 pm
Try any of the garden centres outside Sai Kung.