Thought I should mention Monsters vs. Aliens.
As previously noted, there is just one IMAX screen in Hong Kong and they have chosen to screen the Cantonese dubbed 3D IMAX version, with just two showings of the original English – both on weekdays at 5:30 PM. Yes, I understand that most of Hong Kong speaks Cantonese as a first language. Yes, I understand that kids don’t want to read subtitles. But is that any excuse to not do at least some 10 PM or midnight screenings in the original English?
And with a voice cast that includes Reese Witherspoon, Seth Rogen, Hugh Laurie, Kiefer Sutherland, Rainn Wilson, Will Arnett, Stephen Colbert, Paul Rudd, Jeffrey Tambor, Amy Poehler, Renee Zellweger and John Krasinski, would anyone choose to view this dubbed by a bunch of local also-rans and never-wases, probably under the direction of the local marketing manager, rather than the original voice cast under the direction of the film’s actual directors?
So there are two local screens showing the 35mm 3-D version in English – at the IFC and Elements shopping malls. We went to the IFC, House #5, a shoebox – 13 rows, 14 seats across, first row practically underneath the screen. HK$120 per ticket, plus $6 per ticket internet booking fee. Sigh. Fortunately we were able to get seats right in the middle of the theater.
Now the disclosure bit – the 3D projection process for MvA was done by a U.S. company called RealD, and a very good friend of mine is president of the division of RealD working to bring 3D to home TVs, computers and even mobile phones.
The movie starts off with the Dreamworks logo in black & white. After a funny bit of animation, the logo screen is torn off, revealing behind it a breathtaking space scape, a planet with rings much like Saturn, and I couldn’t stop myself from saying “Wow!” out loud. It looked really good. And the 3D effect remained great throughout the film, even those bits that weren’t reminiscent of SCTV’s Dr. Tongue’s 3D House of Pancakes.
MvA itself is an okay film. It’s coming from people involved with the Shrek series so the humor is the same – aimed at the kids with a few mild risque bits for the parents and lots of pop culture references (including a nice CE3K reference that my gf didn’t get at all – reminder to self to show her that film soon)(the day before I gave her a choice between Casino and Pulp Fiction and she went for Sharon Stone).
Most of the jokes are okay, it sagged a little in the middle and the end wasn’t quite as strong as I might have liked, but there is certainly room for a franchise here, plus lots of associated toys, videogames and action figures. Basically I wanted more BOB, more Seth Rogen, and more characters like that one. Almost any time Rogen opened his “mouth” I was laughing and I enjoyed the vaguely anarchic characteristics they gave to BOB – a couple more BOBs and this would have been a classic. (How is it that Rogen seems to be in a new movie every month and I’ve yet to grow tired of him? He had 7 movies in 2008 and has at least 5 this year.) As it is, it’s a harmless and mostly entertaining way to spend 90 minutes.
MvA scored 73% at Rotten Tomatoes and just 58% with “top critics.”
They also showed 3-D trailers for Ice Age 3-D and Coraline. Seeing as how Coraline comes from a Neil Gaiman book and is directed by Henry Selick (Nightmare Before Christmas), and scored much higher with critics than MvA, I’d rank that as a must see as well. It opened in the U.S. on February 9th, we finally get it on April 30th.
Oh, by the way, the Palace’s retrospective series is doing Jacques Tati, I suppose to coincide with our annual “Le French May” marketing whatchamacallit. Writer/director/star Tati was the greatest film comedian to ever come out of France (even if it is a country not particularly well known for its sense of humor). He only directed 9 films. Only 9! But you must see Monsieur Hulot’s Holiday, Mon Oncle, Playtime and Traffic – they are also available in great editions from Criterion. (And, to be honest, they make films like MvA look like poo.)