From The Independent, via Rebecca Mackinnon:
The International Olympic Committee (IOC) will launch an inquiry into internet censorship in China after accusations that Beijing was failing to live up to its promises guaranteeing unrestricted online access.
Furious reporters are finding that their internet access is inadequate. Attempts to use the network to access the website of Amnesty International, which has just released a damning report on human rights in China, proved fruitless yesterday.
There was also an embarrassing moment for the Chinese when one journalist whipped out his laptop at a news conference to show how sites including the BBC’s China service fell foul of the Great Firewall of China. Suggestions that it was a technical problem were laughed off.
China has promised to allow the 20,000 accredited journalists the same working conditions they enjoyed at previous Games.
The IOC’s press chief, Kevin Gosper, said he would investigate any apparent efforts to interfere with the reporters doing their jobs.
All taken care of, right? Ahhhhh, not so much.
From the NY Times today:
The Chinese government has confirmed what journalists arriving at the lavishly outfitted media center here have suspected: contrary to previous assurances by Olympic and government officials, the Internet will be censored during the upcoming Games.
The International Olympic Committee quietly agreed to some of the limitations, according to a press official, Kevin Gosper, the Reuters news agency reported. Mr. Gosper told Reuters on Wednesday that he had only just learned of the agreement. Sandrine Tonge, the I.O.C. media relations coordinator, said the organization would press the Chinese authorities to reconsider the limits.
Since the Olympic Village press center opened on Friday, reporters have been unable to access scores of Web pages — among them those that discuss Tibetan succession, Taiwanese independence, the violent crackdown of the protests in Tiananmen Square and the sites of Amnesty International, Radio Free Asia and several Hong Kong newspapers known for their freewheeling political discourse.
A government spokesman initially suggested the problems originated with the site hosts, but on Wednesday, he acknowledged that journalists would not have unfettered Internet use during the Games, which begin Aug. 8.
…
In the past, both the Chinese government and the International Olympic Committee have suggested that the 20,000 journalists covering the Games would have full Internet access. As recently as two weeks ago, Jacques Rogge, the International Olympic committee president, proclaimed to Agence France-Presse: “For the first time, foreign media will be able to report freely and publish their work freely in China. There will be no censorship on the Internet.”
I love that next to last paragraph above, so typically China – lie about it as long as you can.
Basically, China promised the IOC everything it asked for. And then it reneged on all those promises because the Olympics are a week away and what is the IOC going to do about it? I mean, what is a promise anyway, just words, right? Why were there so many people who didn’t want China to get the Olympics? Why are there so many people hoping the event is a colossal failure?
But the one thing you can’t call China is “stupid.” They knew what they were doing all along. If anyone comes out looking stupid from all this, it’s the idiots running the IOC who get that tag, for believing whatever they were told and for not having proper safeguards in place in case covenants were broken, as they clearly have been, over and over and fucking over again.
Incidentally, here is Amnesty International’s statement on the censorship:
In reaction to the IOC statement, Mark Allison, East Asia researcher for Amnesty International said: “The International Olympic Committee and the Organizing Committee of the Beijing Olympic Games should fulfil their commitment to ‘full media freedom’ and provide immediate uncensored internet access at Olympic media venues. Censorship of the internet at the Games is compromising fundamental human rights and betraying the Olympic values.
“This blatant media censorship adds one more broken promise that undermines the claim that the Games would help improve human rights in China,” said Mark Allison.
Expect the Chinese government to either keep quiet or blame westerners for meddling their internal affairs. And Lee Kuan Yew from his pulpit in Singapore will once again sermonize about how western democracy and freedoms don’t apply to Asia.
Here’s a link to the Amnesty Report, People’s Republic of China: The Olympics Countdown – Broken Promises.
With the Olympics less than two weeks away, it is time to assess progress made by the Chinese authorities to improve human rights in line with their own commitments made in 2001 when the International Olympic Committee (IOC) chose Beijing to host the Games. Regrettably, since the publication of Amnesty International’s last Olympics Countdown report on 1 April 2008, there has been no progress towards fulfilling these promises, only continued deterioration. Unless the authorities make a swift change of direction, the legacy of the Beijing Olympics will not be positive for human rights in China.
……
In fact, the crackdown on human rights defenders, journalists and lawyers has intensified because Beijing is hosting the Olympics. The authorities have stepped up repression of dissident voices in their efforts to present an image of “stability” and “harmony” to the outside world. This has resulted in the detention and imprisonment of those who wish to draw attention to the other side of the picture, which includes human rights violations perpetrated in preparation for the Games.
…
The IOC’s diplomatic, non-public approach on human rights cases and issues does not appear to have yielded significant results. International pressure from other governments for human rights reform has also been insufficient, sending a message that it is acceptable for a government to host the Olympic Games in an atmosphere characterised by repression and persecution. The danger now becomes that after the Olympic Games these patterns of serious human rights violations may continue or intensify with even less attention paid by the international community than has been the case so far.
I ain’t watching this shit, I ain’t buying tickets, I ain’t buying souvenir merchandise.